Blues Traveler
What You and I Have Been Through
(ARTISTDirect/BMG)
First Appeared at The Music Box, December 2002, Volume 9, #12
Written by John Metzger
Blues Traveler’s recent album Bridge should have erased any doubts that the band was back and at the top of its game. However, those desiring proof that the group’s concert performances have also suffered little since the passing of bassist Bobby Sheehan need look no further than What You and I Have Been Through, the first in what promises to be a regular series of live recordings. That’s not to take anything away from Sheehan, whose untimely death — another rock ’n‘ roll tragedy — left some might big shoes to fill. But Tad Kinchla has done much more than just an admirable job, allowing the band to continue without skipping a beat.
For the record, more than half of What You and I Have Been Through features songs that also appear on Bridge. But like any jam band worth its weight in gold, Blues Traveler blows them wide open, offering different interpretations that are as good — if not better — than the originals. Most notable is an expansive rendition of Rage, on which guitarist Chan Kinchla and guest saxophonist Carl Young intermingle solos over the song’s writhing rhythm. Equally strong is an intense coupling of You Lost Me There and All Hands as well as a powerful pairing of Carolina Blues and the previously unavailable tune Pattern.
Nevertheless, What You and I Have Been Through isn’t without its share
of oddities. Despite the many tremendous versions of Blues Traveler’s songs that are contained on
the album, it’s not as cohesive a concert document as the band’s two-disc set
Live from the Fall. Indeed, as All Hands begins to mutate into Run Around,
the song fades out. Granted, the world might not need another take on this overplayed, yet classic
tune, but the abrupt ending is a bit jarring, to say the least. Likewise, the disc’s final cut (a
hip-hop rendition of The Path, featuring Radioactive) drifts off into silence before reaching
its conclusion. No doubt, both of these edits were designed to fit as much quality music as possible
onto this 72-minute album, but in both cases, the listener is left hanging mid-groove. That might
not be a problem for some bands, but for one such as Blues Traveler, whose fans tend not to ignore
the music but to sink into it as it’s happening, this is akin to climbing Mt. Everest and stopping
before one can catch the view from its summit. Still, What You and I Have Been Through
succeeds, in spite of itself, as a testament to the potency of Blues Traveler’s legacy. 
Ratings
1 Star: Pitiful
2 Stars: Listenable
3 Stars: Respectable
4 Stars: Excellent
5 Stars: Can't Live Without It!!
Copyright © 2002 The Music Box