Toots and the Maytals
True Love
(V2)
First Appeared at The Music Box, May 2004, Volume 11, #5
Written by John Metzger
It’s likely that True Love will become the biggest selling album of Frederick "Toots" Hibbert’s career, yet the music contained therein leaves one feeling somewhat less than satisfied. Formed in the early ’60s, Toots and the Maytals helped to make Jamaican music an international phenomenon, but although Hibbert penned the 1968 song Do the Reggay, which gave the movement its name, he forever has been overshadowed by Bob Marley, Jimmy Cliff, and Peter Tosh. His new outing undoubtedly is meant to correct this lingering injustice, and — save for a cover of Willie Nelson’s Still Is Still Moving to Me — all of its fifteen tracks are reinterpretations of songs that stretch across a 40-year span of the Maytals’ glorious career.
Even more intriguing is that throughout True Love, Hibbert is surrounded by a myriad of guest performers, all of whom have been touched by his music; it’s an impressive list that includes everyone from Jeff Beck to Shaggy, from Bootsy Collins and The Roots to Rachael Yamagata, and from Bonnie Raitt to Trey Anastasio. Yet, with all this star-power present, the collection takes on the aura of a tribute album — albeit one which was crafted within the presence of its subject — rather than a magnificent, new introduction to a legend.
For the record, none of the tracks on True Love are truly calamitous,
but then again, none break any new ground either. While the guests emphatically
make their presence known, their approach to doing so remains far too reverent,
as if they are all content simply to flit about the music with tasteful
discretion. Even more troubling is the notion that many of the pairings
frequently fail to achieve the type of chemistry necessary to make a series of
collaborations such as this succeed. While Eric Clapton adds some wah-wah guitar
muscle to Pressure Drop, for example, his contributions sound as if they
were recorded separately from the rest of the ensemble. Likewise, on Time
Tough, Ryan Adams’ call-and-response mimicry of Hibbert’s vocals is
inessential and intrusive. Perhaps the biggest deficiency of all, however, is
that the new renditions largely fail to match the soulful transcendence of the
Maytals’ originals. The end result is that although True Love will expose
the group’s music to a much wider audience, it’s not the type of compelling
collection necessary to convert incontestably a new generation of fans. 
47th Annual Grammy Award Winner:
Best Reggae Album
Of Further Interest...
Burning Spear - Living Dub, Volume 6
Peter Tosh - The Essential Peter Tosh
True Love is available from Barnes & Noble.
To order, Click Here!
Ratings
1 Star: Pitiful
2 Stars: Listenable
3 Stars: Respectable
4 Stars: Excellent
5 Stars: Can't Live Without It!!
Copyright © 2004 The Music Box