Year in Review: 2007's Most Memorable Songs

First Appeared in The Music Box, December 2007, Volume 14, #12

Written by John Metzger

Thu December 20, 2007, 07:00 AM CST


Lucinda Williams - West1) Lucinda Williams - Are You Alright?

Are You Alright?, the opening cut from her latest endeavor West, arguably is the most grief-stricken song that Lucinda Williams ever has penned. Lost and lonely, she ponders the well-being of an ex-lover, but the way in which Williams repeats the title phrase over and over again makes it sound as if she is the one who needs to be comforted. The surrounding arrangement lends a ghostly quality to the tune, which allows it also to fit quite comfortably with the other focal point of the album: the death of Williamsí mother. Are You Alright? is the sound of a heart that has been battered and broken by life, and it is a plea for assistance to anyone who happens to be listening.

Full Review of Lucinda Williams' West


Patti Scialfa - Play It as It Lays2) Patti Scialfa - Play It As It Lays

Whether Bruce Springsteen really cheated on his spouse is up for debate. Believing that it happened, however, makes Play It As It Lays, Patti Sciafaís latest effort, resonate with even greater force. She delivers the title track in a relaxed and nearly unassuming fashion, but as the words roll off her tongue, she unforgettably paints a mood that contains both sadness and hope. As she wanders through her memories, she finds strength where she least expects it, and as a result, her initial resignation is transformed into a desire to reignite the embers of love that still glow in her heart.

Full Review of Patti Scialfa's Play It As It Lays


Robert Plant / Alison Krauss - Raising Sand3) Robert Plant/Alison Krauss - Killing the Blues

Robert Plant and Alison Kraussí Raising Sand is full of understated beauty. None of its tracks, however, are quite as soft, ethereal, and lovely ó or as crushing ó as Killing the Blues. Over the course of the tune, the voices of Plant and Krauss are intertwined in a delicate dance with Greg Leiszís pedal steel accompaniment, and the results are positively heavenly. Considering that the song floats by as gently as a whisper, Killing the Blues leaves behind an impression that is tremendously deep.

Full Review of Robert Plant & Alison Krauss's Raising Sand


Radiohead - In Rainbows4) Radiohead - House of Cards

"I donít want to be your friend/I just want to be your lover," croons Thom Yorke on House of Cards, a song that serves as the turning point of sorts for Radioheadís latest effort In Rainbows. Yorke has never sounded as seductive as he does here, nor has it ever been this easy to understand what heís singing. House of Cards is a song about infidelity, though in the grander scheme of In Rainbows, it also highlights the ways in which people wrestle with love. The music that surrounds him is beguiling and romantic, yet, it also portentously encapsulates the reluctance in his lyrics. Unable to resist, he follows the song of the Sirens, knowing with no uncertainty that he inevitably is doomed.

Full Review of Radiohead's In Rainbows


Lyle Lovett - It's Not Big It's Large5) Lyle Lovett - South Texas Girl

South Texas Girl is the sound of Lyle Lovett getting back to basics, and suitably, it finds him wistfully reflecting upon his childhood, while lamenting how the times have changed. Delivered as a warm, gentle waltz and featuring the weathered vocals of Guy Clark, South Texas Girl is as much about love and life as it is about the formative moments that quietly turn kids into adults. The songís images and emotions combine to form something that is cinematic in scope, which in turn is what ultimately makes this slice of nostalgia work as well as it does.

Full Review of Lyle Lovett's It's Not Big It's Large


Fountains of Wayne - Traffic and Weather6) Wilco - What Light

Although there are better tracks to be found on the endeavor, Sky Blue Skyís most ingratiatingly accessible point of entry is What Light. Considering how experimental Wilco has become in recent years, it is somewhat surprising how simple What Lightís lyrics and music are. Like a modern day rendition of The Band performing a time-tested tune from Bob Dylan or Woody Guthrie, Wilco uses What Light to draw closer to its alt-country roots than it has been in quite some time. Infused with an air of determination, the song builds to a full head of steam until it becomes a mantra for following oneís heart.

Full Review of Wilco's Sky Blue Sky


Trey Anastasio - The Horseshoe Curve7) Trey Anastasio - The 5th Round / The Horseshoe Curve

Stuffed squarely into the center of Trey Anastasioís uneven outing The Horseshoe Curve are two tracks that were culled from his archive of concert recordings. Not only do these tunes (The 5th Round / The Horseshoe Curve) serve as the heart and soul of the endeavor, but they also give to the collection the sort of focus that saves it from being tossed onto the scrap heap of enjoyable yet otherwise forgettable moments from Anastasioís solo career. Filled with percolating rhythms that are punctuated by ringing blasts of horns, The 5th Round and The Horseshoe Curve form one, long, jazz-rock groove that ranks among the best things that the former Phish guitarist ever has committed to tape. Thereís no question that these cuts are likely to appeal only to those who frequent the jam band and jazz-fusion scenes. Yet, they also feature the kind of inspired improvisation that these same fans desperately need to hear.

Full Review of Trey Anastasio's The Horseshoe Curve


John Fogerty - Revival8) John Fogerty - I Canít Take It No More

Over the past few years, John Fogerty relentlessly has assaulted the Bush Administration for its policies both at home and abroad. Despite his best efforts at pouring his concerns into his work, he nonetheless still has enough venom left to unleash a ferocious tirade like I Canít Take It No More. The song essentially is a í50s tune ó think Chuck Berry or Little Richard ó that is revved up considerably until it explodes in a blast of punk-driven fury. Itís so simple that it borders upon being a complete throwaway. Yet, like any good garage rock anthem, its bilious rage also is utterly therapeutic, at least to those who agree with his sentiments, which, judging from the polls, is most of the country.

Full Review of John Fogerty's Revival


John Mellencamp - Freedom's Road9) John Mellencamp - Rural Route

John Mellencampís music always has been a hybridization of country, blues, and folk styles, but too often, he has transplanted his material in the unfertile ground of radio-friendly pop. Trouble No More, his 2003 collection of cover tunes, revealed a lot about the kinds of artists with which he wanted his own work to be associated, and Rural Route is his first tune to not follow the path down which he usually heads. Its subject matter likely had something to do with altering his approach. By telling the tale of a little girl from Indiana whose fatherís crystal meth habit gets her sexually assaulted and slaughtered, Mellencamp forced himself to break free from his usual routine. Although Rural Route is not an easy song to embrace, it nonetheless is the most haunting thing he ever has written, and it bodes well for his collaboration with T Bone Burnett, which is slated for release in early 2008.

Full Review of John Mellencamp's Freedom's Road


Amy Winehouse - Back to Black10) Amy Winehouse - Rehab

Amy Winehouseís Rehab has an insistent melody that is impossible to shake. It helps, of course, that it also sounds as if it was produced by Phil Spector back in the 1960s. The events of the past 12 months have been akin to a ride on a roller coaster for Winehouse. As a result, Rehabís emotional contours have been altered dramatically. Instead of defiant posturing, it now comes shrouded in the darker context of an artist who sadly refuses to get the help she needs to survive. For everyone else, itís still a lot of fun to sing.

Full Review of Amy Winehouse's Back to Black


For additional information, please also see our other Best of 2007 Lists


Copyright © 2007 The Music Box